Skokie, News

The Record sues Surround Sound Media for allegedly lifting, republishing its original work

The Record Community News, publisher of The Record North Shore, has sued another digital media company for copyright infringement, alleging in a formal complaint that the owner of North Shore Weekly systematically and improperly republished The Record’s original reporting and photography. 

The complaint, filed on Monday, Nov. 9, in U.S. District Court, claims Surround Sound Media, a Chicago-based company that reportedly operates www.northshoreweekly.com, reproduced copyrighted content from The Record’s website at least 22 different times between June 18-July 23.

“Rather than independently report the news,” the complaint alleges, North Shore Weekly published lightly rewritten articles and photographs owned by The Record, a nonprofit newsroom based in Wilmette, with original bylines, credits, captions and other copyright management information removed or altered.

Demanding a jury trial, the complaint requests the court order Surround Sound to cease “further copying, reproducing, distributing, publicly displaying, or preparing derivative works”; delete its existing allegedly copied works; and award The Record up to $25,000 per copyright violation.

Hilary Loewenstein, Surround Sound Media’s head of strategic growth, said in an email that she has “no comment” on the pending litigation.

North Shore Weekly competes directly with The Record “for the same readers in the same communities,” the complaint argues, adding that the republication of The Record’s work “diverts readership, advertising and sponsorship value, donor and subscriber support, and goodwill from Plaintiff to Defendants.”

Joe Coughlin, co-founder and editor-in-chief of The Record, said the organization filed the lawsuit in order to “protect” the local nonprofit newsroom’s work and stand up for small publishers encountering apparent copyright violations. 

“We work really hard to produce independent and original local news every single day, and we allege that that work was used inappropriately and without authorization,” Coughlin said. “Those alleged actions are a threat to the work itself, to the work of small publishers, and to the community that relies upon that work and that credible information.”

The lawsuit invokes the Copyright Act of 1976, which gives copyright owners exclusive rights over their original creative works, and the Digital Millennium Copyright Act of 1998, which prohibits removing or altering the names of authors or other copyright information from works.

The Record’s complaint alleges that Surround Sound Media employs “automated software, including data-gathering pipelines and automated, multi-step content-generation processes, to collect, generate, and publish local news content” across many communities at scale. 

In one example, The Record published an article on July 5, 2026, about the Village of Winnetka opening a 50-year-old time capsule. 

Penelope Roewe, a former temporary employee with The Record, is that article’s author and photographer. Both the article’s text and lead photograph were registered with the U.S. Copyright Office, the complaint says. 

According to The Record’s lawsuit, North Shore Weekly published an article on July 7, 2026, about the same Village of Winnetka time capsule ceremony, and while the North Shore Weekly article appears to no longer be accessible, screenshots included in the complaint show the article used the same lead photo as The Record’s article but the photo’s credit was changed to: “(Courtesy: The Record).”

The North Shore Weekly article, which attributes a byline to Ellie Nevel, also “copied original, protectable expression” from the text of Roewe’s article, The Record’s lawsuit alleges. 

A spokesperson for Surround Sound emailed The Record a statement that says the company’s mission is to “give Chicagoland residents reliable information about their schools, local government, businesses and neighbors, creating a shared foundation of facts for community life.” 

The statement adds, “In our hybrid newsrooms, journalists set the coverage agenda, choose sources and make the final decisions about what we publish. AI tools help monitor public records, identify developments and prepare drafts, which journalists check against source material, edit and put into context before publication.”

The complaint states that The Record “invests substantial time, skill, labor, and expense to produce original journalism and photography.” The nonprofit news organization employs full-time editorial staff and engages staff and freelance reporters and photographers to create works for publication.

Coughlin said he was first notified by North Shore residents in June 2026 that The Record’s work appeared to be reproduced on another website. 

As The Record publishes approximately four unique articles online each weekday, Coughlin said the time and financial cost to register every single work with the U.S. Copyright Office is not prudent for the organization. 

The lawsuit includes 18 examples of North Shore Weekly allegedly reproducing copyrighted text elements and nine examples of it allegedly reproducing copyrighted photos originally posted on The Record’s website between the window of June and July 2026. 

All 27 works allegedly had their copyright information removed or altered.

The lawsuit also lists Robert Kellman, who reportedly founded and manages Surround Sound Media, as the “moving, active, conscious force behind the infringement alleged” in the complaint.

Kellman “conceived, created, and operated the Surround Sound platform and its automated content processes; he personally participates in, directs, controls, authorizes, and ratifies the copying and republication” of The Record’s works, the lawsuit claims. 

Surround Sound’s website shows the company operates many other local content websites, with more than 170 “newsrooms” across the entire country.


The Record is a nonprofit, nonpartisan community newsroom that relies on reader support to fuel its independent local journalism.

Become a member of The Record to fund responsible news coverage for your community.

Already a member? You can make a tax-deductible donation at any time.


Samuel Lisec

Samuel Lisec is a Chicago native and Knox College alumnus with years of experience reporting on community and criminal justice issues in Illinois. Passionate about in-depth local journalism that serves its readers, he has been recognized for his investigative work by the state press association.

Related Stories