Winnetka, News

Evanston residents confront New Trier School Board on Ryan Field slurs; NT officials say investigation continues

Evanston community members continue to demand action from New Trier High School exactly one month after Evanston Township High School band members said New Trier students shouted racist and homophobic slurs toward them during the rivals’ football game at Northwestern University’s Ryan Field.

More than 40 Evanston residents, many of whom identified themselves as ETHS alumni, packed a New Trier multipurpose room on Nov. 16, with 18 of them speaking up to demand accountability for those actions.

Following the Oct. 16 game and accusations, the high schools joined in an investigation that confirmed the behavior but could not positively identify the perpetrators, according to New Trier officials.

Accountability, Partnership ‘Timeout’

Evanston community members fill seats to confront the New Trier School Board on Nov. 16. | Photo by Peter Kaspari/The Record North Shore

Many of the speakers and audience members were Black and shared their experiences with racism in front of the School Board while also pressing New Trier officials to take action.

Michael Nabors, president of the Evanston chapter of the NAACP, said what happened at the Oct. 16 game is just one example of racism at school sporting events, listing off other incidents including racist actions caught on video during a September football game between Homewood-Flossmoor and Lincoln-Way East high schools.

He said the NAACP is demanding that New Trier hold the students involved accountable.

“If we do not publicly denounce such abhorrent behavior in our children today, the adults of tomorrow will not be able to move our area, our state or our nation forward in the right direction,” he said. “And the road towards ending racism and homophobia and any other isms is a long one, but it begins with two steps: accepting responsibility and taking action and sharing that with the community.”

Meleika Gardner, a 1988 ETHS graduate, said she experienced racism from New Trier students during her time in high school. She called for an end to New Trier and Evanston’s athletic relationship.

“We need to suspend the games with ETHS. The relationship is over,” she said. “And I’m saying that because I want our children to be safe.”

Gardner accused New Trier of not knowing how to address racism and said racism is “embedded” in the students who use it.

We need a timeout so that you can really think about what it’s going to take [to address racism]”
Martha Burns, former ETHS School Board member talking about the partnership between New Trier and Evanston high schools

Former ETHS School Board member Martha Burns also supported ending the relationship between New Trier and Evanston.

“We need to end the relationship on both sides,” she said. “We need a timeout so that you can really think about what it’s going to take [to address racism].”

Burns also called on the School Board to support New Trier Superintendent Dr. Peter Tragos in the investigation.

“As board members, you have an obligation,” she said. “It’s not easy at these times to do what you’ve got to do. It’s not just on your superintendent.”

Jennifer Sadler, who also spoke at the board’s October meeting, is the parent of one of the ETHS marching band students harassed at the game. She talked about her child, who identifies as nonbinary and uses they/them pronouns, and the hard work they put into marching band.

Sadler also said a number of New Trier students had spoken to her and said they were “disheartened” by what happened. She went on to encourage the students who were there to speak up.

“You can’t censor yourself,” Sadler said. “I know it’s hard not to, but you can’t censor yourself when your peers have hurt other people. And if you feel like they don’t represent you, you have to be louder than them.”

New Trier promises to continue work

New Trier Superintendent Dr. Peter Tragos addresses attendees of the meeting.

Both Tragos and School Board President Sally Tomlinson promised the investigations would continue.

Tragos said he attended a recent ETHS School Board meeting where he spoke with parents and community members, many of whom he said were also at New Trier’s board meeting.

He also said while the actions of a few students should not be a reflection on all of New Trier, “we have a responsibility to listen and to act when students tell us they have experienced racism and homophobia and other forms of discrimination at our school and our community. We have a responsibility to take ownership of our actions.”

He said that staff professional development in the coming months will focus on connecting New Trier’s values with daily expectations, and how adults and students should handle hateful behavior.

“Our values and expectations must be clear and explicit,” Tragos said. “Our response to violations of those expectations must be immediate and consistent, and we must equip our students to put these expectations into practice.”

Tomlinson said the Ryan Field incidents are a “call to action for us to examine where our current programs fall short,” specifically with behavior and compassion.

She said work on addressing those issue is “evolving and never-ending” and promised partnerships can be formed.

“I don’t know what those partnerships will look like, but I do appreciate the ongoing outreach and willingness for so many of you to engage,” she said, “and many of you have come to speak before us tonight and offered that help. I appreciate that and I thank you.”


The Record is a nonprofit, nonpartisan community newsroom that relies on reader support to fuel its independent local journalism.

Become a member of The Record to fund responsible news coverage for your community.

Already a member? You can make a tax-deductible donation at any time.

Peter Kaspari

Peter Kaspari is a blogger and a freelance reporter. A 10-year veteran of journalism, he has written for newspapers in both Iowa and Illinois, including spending multiple years covering crime and courts. Most recently, he served as the editor for The Lake Forest Leader. Peter is also a longtime resident of Wilmette and New Trier High School alumnus.

Related Stories